Thorum vs. Staghead Designs: Which Ring Brand Is Right for You?
When it comes to non-traditional wedding rings, Thorum and Staghead Designs are two of the most talked-about names—each with a fiercely loyal following. Both brands craft rings using rare materials like meteorite, antler, whiskey barrel wood, and Damascus steel. But beneath the surface, they offer very different experiences. If you're deciding between them, this breakdown will help you choose the right fit—whether you value speed, personalization, or peace of mind.
Quick Comparison Table
| Feature | Thorum | Staghead Designs |
|---|---|---|
| Origin | Family-owned, Florida (est. 2012) | Family-owned, Utah (est. 2011) |
| Materials | Meteorite, whiskey barrel, dinosaur bone, tungsten | Antler, turquoise, Damascus, personal embeds |
| Customization | Curated designs, minor custom options | Full custom design available |
| Price Range | $250–$800 (avg. $300–$600) | $400–$1,500+ |
| Style | Modern, bold, durable | Rustic, folk-inspired, natural |
| Warranty | Lifetime (includes loss) | Limited (lifetime only with paid plan) |
| Shipping | 1–2 business days | 4–8+ weeks (custom) |
| Return Policy | 30 days (with restocking fee) | Final sale on custom orders |
| Extras | Free silicone band + wood box | Wood box, story card (varies by order) |
| Social Proof | 5,000+ verified reviews, fast support, Reddit/YouTube presence | 4.8★ avg. on WeddingWire/The Knot, some BBB complaints |
Thorum: Durable, Story-Driven, Ready When You Are
Thorum rings are known for combining exotic materials with modern craftsmanship. Think meteorite and dinosaur bone in a single design. With over 5,000 five-star reviews, their trust signals are hard to miss. Thorum’s lifetime warranty even covers lost rings, and their Florida workshop ships most orders in 1 business day.
Thorum isn’t focused on bespoke design. Instead, each ring is already its own limited-edition—no two pieces of whiskey barrel wood or meteorite will ever be identical. For buyers who want something rare, meaningful, and reliable without the wait, Thorum nails the experience.
Staghead Designs: Custom, Earthy, Deeply Personal
Staghead thrives on personalization. Customers can design from scratch or modify existing models using antler, turquoise, pet fur, or even sand from a memorable trip. Each ring becomes a co-created story. Their aesthetic is distinctly rustic—mountain engravings, woodland textures, and a strong handmade ethos.
That said, expect a wait. Custom builds average 6–8 weeks, with some Reddit reviewers reporting 10+ week delays. Staghead's lifetime warranty is available only as a paid add-on, and reviews—while mostly glowing—include frustration over communication gaps and fragility in certain materials (e.g., wood splitting if wet).
Which Brand Is Right for You?
- Choose Thorum if you want: fast shipping, bold materials, high trust, and a bulletproof warranty.
- Choose Staghead Designs if you want: full design control, natural textures, and a deeply personalized process (and don’t mind a wait).
FAQs
Do Thorum rings rust?
Not under normal use. Meteorite is sealed to resist oxidation, and the base metals (like titanium) are known for their durability. Plus, Thorum’s warranty covers damage or replacement.
Can I return a Staghead Designs ring?
Only if it’s a standard model with no customizations. Most Staghead rings are final sale due to being made-to-order.
Which materials last longer: meteorite or antler?
Meteorite is tougher but can rust if not sealed properly. Antler is softer and can crack if exposed to water or extreme wear. Thorum stabilizes meteorite inlays for daily use; Staghead stabilizes antler but includes care guidelines.
Does Thorum really replace lost rings?
Yes. Their lifetime warranty includes a one-time remake for lost rings—no charge. It’s one of the most generous warranties in the industry.
How fast is Thorum shipping compared to Staghead?
Thorum usually ships within 1–2 business days. Staghead orders take 4–8 weeks or more, depending on customization.
Still deciding? Check out Thorum’s Meteorite Collection or see why thousands trust us with their most meaningful piece: Read Reviews.
Leave a comment